Skip to content

Search Engine Optimization

AI Mode Gets Gemini 4 Carbon, but Only for Ultra Subscribers

Google has started putting Carbon into AI Mode in Search, but only for Ultra subscribers.

A woman types a question into a laptop at a sunny desk in Dubai, with the text: Carbon reaches AI Mode, for Ultra only
Adnika 13 min read 2,967 words
Share in X
Contents9
  1. The 10 November change to AI Mode in Search
  2. Access to Carbon in AI Mode depends on your plan
  3. AI Mode vs AI Overviews, and the system underneath
  4. Google's post is silent on search ads and citations
  5. Carbon in AI Mode means a small, paying audience for now
  6. The UAE teams this AI Mode update touches
  7. AI Mode checks for Dubai businesses this month
  8. Gemini API pricing for teams that build on Carbon
  9. How we're reading the update at Adnika

Google has changed what writes some of the answers in AI Mode, and only its most expensive consumer plan gets the change. On 10 November, Google began rolling out Gemini 4 Carbon to people who pay for Google AI Ultra. It reaches them in three places, and AI Mode in Search is the one that matters to anyone who earns clicks from Google search. The details below come from Google's announcement as reported by PPC Land.

Carbon isn't a replacement for Argon, which Google released on 13 October as the first of the new generation. Google sets them side by side: Carbon for the hardest multi-step coding and research, Argon for most other work. For businesses that rely on search traffic, the shortest line in the post matters most. Carbon is rolling out to all Ultra subscribers in AI Mode, so it now writes some of what they read before they click.

Google's announcement covers developers, businesses and consumers in one post. It calls Carbon the company's strongest system so far, with its gains in complex tasks that run over many steps. Google says Carbon spends more tokens than Argon to explore a problem, reason through it and verify the result. Keep that in mind, because it shapes the bill for anyone building on the API.

For searchers, the change sits in AI Mode. AI Mode is a conversational search experience within Google Search, where you ask a question and get a written answer that cites its sources. Carbon now writes some of those replies for Ultra subscribers. Nothing in the post says the AI search experience changes for anyone else.

The pace of change is the bigger story. AI Mode moved to Gemini 3.8 Flash on 2 September and took on Argon for Pro and Ultra subscribers on 13 October. Carbon, for Ultra alone, is the third change to the system behind AI Mode in a little over two months. Every switch changes the text people read first on a search, often before they see a single link to a website.

Google first gave Carbon to a group of cybersecurity defenders two weeks before the wider launch, through Fairwind, its access scheme for them. Alphabet's chief executive had already named Carbon when the company reported results on 28 October. Less than two weeks later, it began rolling out in AI Mode for paying subscribers. For search marketers and SEOs, the lesson is that a new release can reach AI Mode in Search within weeks.

Access to Carbon in AI Mode depends on your plan

The consumer route is the narrowest Google has drawn for this generation. Everyday users can only try Carbon in AI Mode in Search and the Gemini app if they pay for Google AI Ultra. PPC Land reports that Ultra is the most expensive of Google's consumer AI plans. When Argon reached AI Mode, it went to both AI Pro and Ultra subscribers, and Pro is the cheaper of the two.

By PPC Land's sums, the entry price for Carbon is five times the plan that was enough for Argon. Google's post quotes no consumer prices at all. Free accounts are further back. Since 9 October, free users of Google's AI assistant have kept only Flash-Lite, after losing access to Flash and Pro.

Nothing in the post points to free access to Carbon. It also doesn't say whether Ultra subscribers can still pick Argon once Carbon arrives. Google hasn't said how many people pay for Ultra either, so nobody outside the company knows how many searches Carbon handles.

Outside the consumer plans, the routes are wider. Developers can build with Carbon on the paid tier of the Gemini API, and businesses can reach it through Google's enterprise plans. Enterprises can also use it in CodeMender, Google's code security agent. Researchers can apply for six months of free access, subject to Google's selection.

Cybersecurity teams can apply to Fairwind on a rolling basis. For a Dubai agency or in-house team, the API route matters most, and we return to its cost below.

AI Mode vs AI Overviews, and the system underneath

AI Mode isn't the same product as AI Overviews, and the difference decides how much a model change matters to you. AI Overviews appear at the top of the traditional search results page in an AI-generated summary above the blue links. Most people see them without asking, on search queries where Google decides a summary helps. AI Mode differs from AI Overviews because you choose to enter it from the search page.

AI Mode is a separate tab next to the usual results in Google Search. To activate AI Mode, you tap that tab, type directly into it or follow the prompt under an AI Overview. From there, AI Mode works as a back-and-forth rather than a one-off search. It feels closer to an AI chat than a results page.

There, users can ask complex questions in plain language and keep the conversation going. AI Mode remembers the context of your previous questions, so you can ask follow-up questions in a few words. That suits multi-part questions, such as comparing two treatments or two suppliers on cost and timing. Inside the tab, AI Mode replaces the familiar list of links with a written answer and its sources.

Behind the scenes, AI Mode uses what Google calls the query fan-out technique. It splits your question into sub-questions, runs them in parallel as separate searches and pulls from multiple sources into one cited response. That's why a single response can name pages that don't rank on the first page for your original query. It's also why the system doing the reasoning matters to anyone whose pages get cited.

Google introduced AI Mode as an experiment in Search Labs, the testing programme that once ran the Search Generative Experience, or SGE. That earlier test became AI Overviews. AI Mode launched as a Labs test too, then reached more users in more markets. Three systems behind it in about ten weeks shows how fast it now changes.

For you, the gap between the two products comes down to intent. AI Overviews give quick answers to people who wanted a traditional search. When people ask AI Mode a question, they usually want to go deeper, compare options and keep asking follow-ups. Those are often the searchers closest to a decision, such as a patient comparing clinics or a buyer checking suppliers in Dubai.

AI Overviews and AI Mode both draw on Google's search index, which holds the pages you already publish. Google hasn't said that Carbon reads or ranks those pages differently. What we know is narrower: for Ultra subscribers, a different system now writes the AI Mode answer, and it reasons for longer before it does. Google is changing AI Mode on more than one front, and we covered another change in our post on the Connected Apps preview for AI Mode.

Google's post is silent on search ads and citations

The post has no sentence about advertising. It gives no information on whether Carbon's replies carry ads in the same places as other AI Mode results. There's no word on whether Carbon cites more or fewer sources than Argon, or how many sources each reply shows. Countries and languages are missing too, although Argon's post had described a global rollout.

Those gaps matter because ads in AI Mode are moving quickly. On 28 October, Google said it was taking those ads to more countries, from Australia and Canada to Nigeria and Singapore. Advertisers got no separate opt-out. In early November, searchers recorded up to four ads beneath a single AI Mode answer.

There's commercial pressure on Google's side as well. In its latest results, Alphabet said the growth of AI Mode queries weighed on search monetisation. The same week, Reddit's chief executive blamed Google's AI-powered search features for falling referrals. We covered his comments in our post on the Reddit CEO's view of Google AI Mode traffic.

Carbon is also absent from Google's advertising products in this announcement. The post doesn't mention Google Ads, Performance Max or any shopping tool. If you run search campaigns on Google Ads in Dubai, nothing here asks you to change budgets or bidding this week. What it does suggest is that you watch where Google places ads around your listings.

We already run ChatGPT Ads campaigns for UAE businesses, so we watch where ads sit inside AI answers. Google's own ads deserve the same attention, because the post gives no sign of where they appear next to Carbon's replies. The post also says nothing about how Google's other generative AI features in Search will use Carbon. For now, the safest reading is that ad placement inside AI Mode can shift without much warning.

Two colleagues review a report on a tablet in a Dubai office, with the text: Track AI Mode before you change budgets

Carbon in AI Mode means a small, paying audience for now

Start with the facts that touch search in the UAE. The post lists no countries, so it doesn't confirm that Ultra subscribers here see Carbon in AI Mode. It doesn't mention Arabic or any other language either. Until Google says more, treat the UAE rollout as unconfirmed.

Even where Carbon is live, it only reaches people on Google's most expensive consumer plan. Most of your customers in Dubai who search in AI Mode are likely to get the systems Google already uses for everyone else. So the direct effect on your search traffic this month is likely to be small. Your visibility in AI Overviews is likely to matter to far more of your buyers than Carbon does today.

The indirect effect is the bigger concern. AI Mode continues to switch systems every few weeks, and each switch can change which pages get cited for the same query. A page quoted in one AI Mode response in October may be missing from the next response in December. AI-generated answers can shift faster than traditional rankings, and a model switch is one reason why.

That isn't a reason to rewrite your site for each release. It's a reason to measure what AI Mode, Google's AI search tool for longer questions, shows for your queries on a schedule. If your content strategy depends on one answer format, Carbon is a reminder that the format will keep moving. Traditional SEO still does the groundwork, because these AI tools quote pages that Google Search can find and trust.

Some people now call this work generative engine optimisation, or GEO. Whatever the label, sound SEO strategies don't need a rewrite for each release. There's no sign in the post that AI Mode rewards content differently now, so the basics still hold.

Pages that answer a clear question early, show who wrote them and back their claims with sources give an AI system something to quote. That work sits at the core of our AI SEO services in Dubai, whichever system sits underneath.

The UAE teams this AI Mode update touches

Three groups in the UAE have a reason to follow Carbon closely. The first is any business whose customers research big decisions on Google Search, such as clinics, property firms and B2B suppliers. Those buyers tend to ask longer questions, which is where AI Mode does its work, and some of them may pay for Ultra.

The second group is agencies and in-house teams that build reports or tools on Google's API. Carbon is open to them now, with a paid API account and no consumer subscription needed. The third is anyone who buys Google Ads, because ads inside AI results keep spreading even though this post ignores them. Each group needs a different plan, so the checks below start with what most businesses share, which is search visibility.

For clinics and property firms in Dubai, the stakes are practical. A buyer who asks AI Mode to compare options may read a summary of your page before they ever visit your site. If that summary is thin or out of date, the click can go to someone else.

AI Mode checks for Dubai businesses this month

You don't need to react to Carbon itself. You do need a routine that catches the next change early, and AI-driven results change often enough to justify one. Use this short guide for the checks we'd run for any Dubai business that wants to remain visible in Google search.

  1. List the queries that bring you enquiries, in English and Arabic, and ask each one in AI Mode once a month.

  2. Check the same queries in AI Overviews and in the search results below them, since traditional rankings and AI picks can differ.

  3. Note which pages each response cites, including your competitors and any third-party directories on the topic.

  4. Put direct answers near the top of your main pages, with a clear structure for the detail and evidence underneath.

  5. Add structured data that matches what each page shows, using schema markup for your organisation, services and FAQs.

  6. Watch the Search Console performance report for those queries and compare its data with the leads that reach your CRM.

  7. Leave your Google Ads budgets alone on this news, since Google hasn't linked Carbon to any ad product.

  8. Keep your opening hours, locations and contact information consistent wherever an AI tool might quote them.

If you'd rather not run these checks alone, our SEO agency in Dubai can track AI Mode results and search rankings for your queries. Either way, start with the search queries that already bring in paying customers.

Gemini API pricing for teams that build on Carbon

Carbon can also power the reporting, analysis and coding tools that agencies build on Google's platform. For those teams, the price looks familiar. Through the API, Carbon costs the same introductory rate per token as Argon, for both input and output. The post doesn't say how long that introductory rate lasts or what replaces it.

The same price per token won't mean the same invoice. Like any large language model (LLM) sold through an API, Carbon is billed by the token. Google says it uses more tokens than Argon to explore and check its work. Every extra token of reasoning is billed at the same output rate.

So the same task can cost more on Carbon whenever it produces more output, as PPC Land points out from Google's own wording. Google gives no ratio between the two systems' token use and no cost comparison per task.

Instead, Google says Carbon ranks first on three outside benchmarks at less than half the cost per task of the strongest external rival. The three are CursorBench 4.0, Perplexity's WANDR and Zapier's AutomationBench. Google doesn't name that rival on any of them, and its own Argon isn't part of the comparison. Anthropic makes similar cost-per-task claims for Claude, also without saying what a task is.

Nearly every claim about generative AI performance in the post comes from Google or from partners it chose. Cost per task can also hide a bigger monthly total, because cheaper tasks can lead teams to run more of them. Google Cloud added project spend caps on 8 October that pause Google's AI agents at the limit. If you build on Carbon, set a cap before you scale and test it against Argon on your own data.

Capacity is the other open question. In October, Google's chief executive said Argon had used a vast volume of tokens early on and that compute was short. Carbon uses more per task than Argon, by Google's own description. The post gives no usage limits for API customers or for subscribers.

The part of the post closest to agency work is about documents. Google says Carbon can pull insights from large sets of dense files and produce polished spreadsheets and decks in strict formats. Client reports, media plans and pitch decks use those formats, so the claim is worth testing on your own work. Its evidence comes from two finance firms that tested Carbon before launch.

A Hebbia engineer quoted in the post praised Carbon for deep financial research and cleaner Excel models. Neither evaluation in the post links to its methods or scores, though. If you run custom tools on the API, compare Carbon and Argon on the same task before you switch. Keep the cheaper option wherever the extra reasoning doesn't change the result.

Google itself says Argon is the right choice for most software and knowledge work. That's worth remembering before you move every workflow to the newer release.

How we're reading the update at Adnika

We don't change a client's plan because one system changed inside one search feature. We change it when the numbers move. The Adnika Dashboard: one live view of a client's ads, analytics and CRM data, with AI recommendations reviewed by the strategist. For an SEO client, it puts search traffic next to the leads that traffic brings in.

If an update moves either one, the change shows up in real enquiries, so nobody has to guess at causes. A simple monthly record of AI Mode answers for your priority search queries makes the next switch easy to read. You'll see which pages Google cited before the change and which it cites after it. That information is worth more than any launch post, Carbon's included.

Three signals from Google would change the picture: a country list, a word on ads and a change in citations. Any one of them would turn a niche launch into a wider change for search in the UAE.

Carbon in AI Mode is a narrow launch today, limited to Ultra subscribers and silent on ads. The next change may reach far more people who search on Google. The businesses that already track their AI Mode answers will spot it sooner and spend less time guessing what happened.

Keep reading

Get a quote

Start a project

Tell us what has stalled

A URL and the number that is not moving is enough. We reply with a real answer, usually the same working day.

Goes to Support@adnika.com. No newsletter, no sequence.